7 tax-loss harvesting myths explained
- Active tax management uses strategies such as tax-loss harvesting and tax-aware rebalancing to help improve after-tax outcomes in taxable investment accounts.
- Tax-loss harvesting can be a valuable planning tool, but its potential benefits depend on factors such as market conditions, your overall tax situation and your investment time horizon.
- Understanding the facts behind common myths can help you decide whether a tax-aware investing approach aligns with your long-term financial goals. Work with a tax professional and your J.P. Morgan advisor to help determine the best approach for you.
In simple terms, tax-loss harvesting is the selling of an investment that has dropped below its original cost basis to realize a loss, reinvesting the proceeds in something similar (but not substantially identical) to maintain your market exposure, and using that loss to defer a taxable gain elsewhere in your portfolio. When implemented thoughtfully, it may help support after-tax returns by deferring gains and potentially reducing tax liabilities that would otherwise be due today.
Harvesting losses is only one piece of a broader practice referred to as active tax management, which is a method of actively managing the investments in your portfolio with the specific goal of optimizing after-tax returns. This approach considers how gains are realized, how an investment portfolio is rebalanced with taxes in mind and how individual tax lots are chosen when a position is sold. Together, these decisions may influence how much of your portfolio returns you are able to keep.
As these strategies have grown more popular, so have the misconceptions around them. Some investors assume tax-aware investing means paying no taxes at all. Others think it guarantees market-beating returns. None of that is right, so let’s walk through what active tax management actually is and clear up the myths that surround it and one of the main engines that drives it: tax-loss harvesting.
What is active tax management?
At its core, active tax management describes any set of decisions made to improve the tax efficiency of a taxable portfolio while staying aligned with your underlying investment goals.
The steps are fairly straightforward: realizing capital losses and managing when gains are realized, with taxes in mind. Technology has made it possible to apply these strategies systematically across individual holdings and to look for tax-saving opportunities throughout the year. This must follow certain rules, such as the wash sale rules, which generally disallow claiming a tax loss if you buy the same or a “substantially identical” security within 30 days before or after selling it at a loss.
The goal isn’t to generate higher pre-tax investment returns, but to take a more disciplined, tax-aware approach to portfolio management – so investors may be able to keep more of what they earn.
Active tax management is mainly for taxable accounts, where taxes on dividends and realized gains can create ongoing “tax drag.” Even within a taxable account, how much potential benefit an investor sees depends heavily on their tax bracket, their other holdings and how long they plan to stay invested.
Interested in working with an advisor?
Work 1:1 with our advisors to help build a personalized financial strategy that’s built around you.
7 common myths about active tax management
Below are seven of the most common myths about tax-aware investing and tax-loss harvesting, along with a more accurate way to think about each one.
Myth 1: Tax-aware means tax-free.
Reality: Tax-aware strategies can defer the taxes an investor owes by managing when gains are realized, but they do not make those taxes disappear.
Why it matters: Deferring taxes can allow more of your money to remain invested over time, potentially benefiting from long-term compounding. In many cases, investors may still owe taxes, depending on their individual circumstances.
Myth 2: If it has tax-loss harvesting, it will always add value.
Reality: The potential value of harvesting depends on volatility, time horizon, tax rate and whether an investor has gains to defer. Some years may present many harvesting opportunities, while others may offer very few.
Why it matters: Tax-loss harvesting should not be viewed as a guaranteed annual return enhancer, but as something that may add after-tax value over time.
Myth 3: Active tax management always beats passive investing.
Reality: The goal is to help improve after-tax outcomes by managing taxable events more efficiently while staying aligned with the chosen investment strategy. The strategy is not designed to outperform low-cost index investing.
Why it matters: Two portfolios may generate similar pre-tax returns, yet the investor who defers their gains may experience better after-tax returns.
Myth 4: Tax-loss harvesting is only for ultra-high-net-worth clients.
Reality: Advances in technology have made automated tax-loss harvesting accessible to a broader range of investors, though minimum investment requirements, fees and available features still vary by brokerage.
Why it matters: The potential to benefit from tax-loss harvesting has less to do with your net worth than with factors such as the size of your taxable portfolio, potential gains and your investment time horizon.
Myth 5: More trading is always bad.
Reality: Frequent trading can increase costs and taxes when done without a clear purpose. However, tax-aware investing may involve strategic trades intended to realize losses or manage realized gains. The objective is not to trade more, but to trade thoughtfully.
Why it matters: It’s not necessarily the number of trades investors should be concerned with, but whether the trading is purposeful, disciplined and mindful of costs.
Myth 6: My advisor can control taxes completely.
Reality: Your overall tax picture depends on far more than just one investment portfolio. You must also consider factors such as additional investment and retirement accounts; other income, state and local taxes; and charitable giving.
Why it matters: Effective tax management requires looking beyond a single portfolio. A portfolio manager can make tax-aware investment decisions, but those must be coordinated with outside accounts when considering your overall financial picture. Reach out to your tax professional for guidance.
Myth 7: Tax-loss harvesting only works in down years.
Reality: Tax-loss harvesting can be useful in many market environments – not just “down years” – because even in flat or rising markets, some holdings may temporarily fall below their purchase price. Realizing those losses can help defer taxable gains (now or in the future) and may improve your tax efficiency, while staying aligned with your investment plan.
Why it matters: If you only look for opportunities when markets are broadly down, you may miss chances to realize losses along the way, potentially leaving tax savings on the table and reducing the after-tax growth of your taxable portfolio.
Tax-aware investing matters because of the hidden tax drag on investment portfolios
The larger point is that taxes can act as a quiet, compounding drag on a portfolio. Any money paid in taxes today can no longer grow on your behalf, and that shortfall can build year after year.
Effective tax management is not simply about maximizing the number of losses realized in a given year. Rather, it seeks to balance tax opportunities with an investment approach that continues to support your financial objectives.
There are real trade-offs when it comes to tax-aware investing. Tax-managed portfolios often hold individual securities rather than funds, so there can be some tracking error (how much a portfolio’s returns differ from those of its benchmark). Tax-loss harvesting can also bring more turnover than a fully passive approach. If you add a lot of personal rules to a portfolio (like “don’t own certain stocks” or “keep this sector small”), it can make it harder to use tax-saving moves as effectively.
Perhaps most importantly, active tax management should never be viewed in isolation. Your income, state and local taxes, along with other holdings outside the managed portfolio and any charitable gifting, all interact with how effective tax management can be, so you should consider taking a holistic approach to the process.
How to evaluate whether active tax management is right for you
To decide whether a tax-smart investing strategy makes sense for your financial situation, consider a few key questions:
- Do you have a meaningful amount of assets in taxable investment accounts?
- Is your investment time horizon long enough to potentially benefit from tax deferral and compounding?
- Do you have realized capital gains or expect to realize gains in the future that harvested losses could help offset?
- Are you comfortable with the possibility that your portfolio may differ from its benchmark because of tax management decisions?
- Will the potential after-tax benefit justify any complexity or customization involved?
These questions are intended as a starting point for discussion with your J.P. Morgan advisor and tax professional, who can help evaluate whether this approach is appropriate for your specific situation.
Success here should be measured by after-tax outcomes over a reasonable stretch of time, not by whether the strategy beats an index every single year.
The bottom line
Active tax management is often misunderstood because investors sometimes expect it to eliminate taxes or consistently outperform the market. In reality, it’s a disciplined approach that seeks to improve tax efficiency while keeping your portfolio aligned with your long-term investment strategy.
Tools such as tax-loss harvesting, tax-aware rebalancing and tax lot management do not eliminate taxes, guarantee outperformance or apply the same way to every investor. What they are designed to do is to help you retain more of your portfolio returns, though results will vary by investor and are not guaranteed. A J.P. Morgan advisor and a tax professional can help evaluate whether this approach is right for you.
Invest your way
Not working with us yet? Find a J.P. Morgan Advisor or explore ways to invest online.
