Payroll tax vs income tax: key differences for small business owners

Learn the difference between the employment taxes most businesses need to withhold: payroll and income tax. Presented by Chase for Business.

Time to read min
      • Payroll tax and income tax are taxes withheld from your employee paychecks that fund government services and social programs.
      • Some payroll taxes, such as Social Security and Medicare taxes, are generally shared by employees and employers. Other employment-related taxes, such as federal and state unemployment taxes, are generally paid by employers.
      • Payroll taxes fund specific federal programs, like Social Security and Medicare, while income taxes help support government services such as education and infrastructure.

      If your business pays employees, you’re responsible for withholding certain federal, state and local taxes from their pay. Whether you run payroll for a team or you’re a business owner handling employment taxes, it can help to understand some key differences between payroll taxes and income tax, as well as how withholding works. Managing those withholdings correctly is an important part of payroll.

       

      What are income taxes?

      Income tax is a tax that federal, state and sometimes local governments charge on an individual's or business's income. Income tax revenue supports many essential government services, such as defense, public infrastructure, education and various social programs.

      You’ll need to withhold the correct amount of income tax for each employee depending on their personal elections and wages earned. Income tax is generally progressive, meaning the rate can increase as employee income goes up.

      Income tax is applied to many types of income, including:

      • Taxable wages and salaries, including employee bonuses
      • Income from investments (such as dividends and capital gains)
      • Earnings from self-employment

       

      How income taxes are paid

      As a business owner, you don't actually pay this tax for your employees; rather, you are required to withhold it from their pay and remit it to the IRS or the applicable state or local tax authorities. However, your employees are ultimately responsible for reconciling their tax withheld with what they owe when filing their tax returns, which may result in a refund or additional payment.

       

      What are payroll taxes?

      Unlike income tax, payroll tax revenue is designated for specific federal programs, namely Social Security and Medicare.

      Payroll tax rates are generally set by law, but the rules vary by tax type. For example, Social Security taxes apply up to an annual wage base, Medicare taxes generally have no wage cap, and additional Medicare withholding may apply above certain income thresholds.

      As a business owner, you must also pay federal unemployment taxes (FUTA) and state unemployment taxes (SUTA) for each employee. These are not withheld from employee paychecks but are paid directly by your business. These taxes, which provide a safety net for workers who lose their jobs, are not deducted or withheld from employee paychecks.

       

      How payroll taxes are paid

      Certain payroll taxes are shared by employees and employers, while others are paid by the employer. Employers are generally responsible for withholding employee taxes when required and remitting both employee and employer amounts by applicable deadlines.

      If you’re self-employed, you generally pay self-employment tax, which is intended to cover the Social Security and Medicare taxes that would otherwise be split between an employer and employee.

       

      Differences between payroll and income tax

      While payroll taxes and income taxes are both deducted from pay, there are a few differences to keep in mind. Understanding these differences may help business owners better understand their tax liabilities and obligations:

      • Purpose: Payroll taxes are dedicated to programs like Social Security and Medicare, while income taxes support a wide variety of government services.
      • Who pays: As a business owner, you pay a portion of payroll taxes and withhold the rest from employees. For income taxes, you withhold the employee’s share and remit it, but do not pay it yourself.
      • Calculation: Payroll tax rates are fixed (subject to wage bases or additional withholding thresholds), whereas income tax rates may rise as employee income increases.
      • Withholding: Employers generally withhold employee income tax and certain employee payroll taxes from wages. Some payroll taxes are shared by employers and employees, while others are paid by employers.
      • Limits: Social Security tax applies only up to an annual wage base, while Medicare tax generally has no wage cap. Income tax applies based on taxable income under applicable federal, state and local rules.
      • Compliance: Business owners must stay compliant in payroll management, which means adhering to federal, state and local laws regarding employee compensation and tax withholding.

       

      How to calculate payroll and income taxes

      Calculating payroll and income taxes is a core part of managing accounting for a small business. Note that you may consider enlisting the help of tax or finance professionals to ensure you’re withholding the correct amounts.

       

      Calculating income tax

      Employees generally complete Form W-4 to provide information used to calculate federal income tax withholding. Employers then apply applicable withholding methods based on the employee’s Form W-4 and wages. Even though an employer doesn’t contribute to an employee's income tax, managing the withholding correctly can help ensure the proper amount is sent to the IRS.

       

      Calculating payroll tax

      Payroll tax is withheld from an employee paycheck with a portion of these taxes paid by both the employer and employee. The type of tax will determine how much is withheld:

      • Social Security taxes: Employees pay 6.2% of their paycheck, and the employer matches the tax for each employee, up to a certain cap.
      • Medicare taxes: The employer and the employee each pay 1.45% of the employee's gross salary into Medicare. Employees who make more than a certain amount pay an additional percentage that employers do not have to match.

      As an employer, you are generally required to withhold these amounts from every paycheck and pay them to the government by the required due date.

      Social Security and Medicare tax rates above are up to date as of August 2026. Rates and thresholds may change. Business owners should confirm current requirements with IRS guidanceOpens overlay or a qualified tax professional.

       

      Best practices for managing payroll and income taxes

      Whether you manage payroll taxes yourself, have a staff member help or outsource payroll tasks, it can be helpful to have dedicated resources. Errors in determining the amount owed, or delays in making payments or filing returns, could lead to fines and other financial penalties that your business may want to avoid.

      Small business owners may help keep their business expenses manageable and their taxes paid on time with these best practices:

      • Enlist the help of experts: Even if you plan to manage payroll in-house, it can be helpful to have an accountant or other tax professional assist you with setting up your records and calculating withholding, especially for salaried workers. Then, use accounting or payroll software to help keep yourself organized.
      • Create pay stubs for each employee: Pay stubs show an employee's gross wages, income and payroll taxes withheld and the net amount they are paid. Having these detailed records can make it easier for you and your workers to file tax returns and other paperwork.
      • Follow federal and state regulations when payments are due: Refer to government guidelines to find employment tax due dates, including which forms are generally required to be filed by what dates and when tax payments are typically required to be deposited. Keeping a calendar of federal, state and local deadlines may help you avoid missing a payment.

      Understanding your tax responsibilities can help protect your business and the people you rely on the most: your team.

       

      Frequently asked questions

       

      What is the main difference between payroll tax and income tax?

      Payroll tax is used for specific government social programs and is split between employees and employers. Income tax is a percentage based on an employee’s total earnings and funds a wide variety of government services.

       

      Who is responsible for paying payroll taxes?

      Both employees and employers contribute to payroll taxes, but some taxes, like FUTA and SUTA, are paid only by the employer. Self-employed individuals generally pay self-employment tax, which covers the employee and employer-equivalent portions of Social Security and Medicare taxes.

       

      Does the business structure affect how payroll taxes are paid?

      Business structure can affect how employment and self-employment taxes apply. Sole proprietors and many partners may owe self-employment tax on business income, while corporations generally treat working owners as employees for wages paid. Business owners should consult a tax professional about their specific structure.

       

      How do self-employed individuals pay income and payroll taxes?

      Self-employed individuals generally pay income tax and self-employment tax through estimated tax payments and/or when filing their annual return. Self-employment tax generally covers Social Security and Medicare taxes.

       

      What happens if payroll or income taxes are not paid on time?

      Late payment or late filing may result in penalties, interest and potential follow-up from tax authorities.

       

      Topics:

      What to read next